Current Font Size:

An e-mail interlocutor reports that someone called Peter alleges on the Grape vanity blog that the only people who read the blogs of wine writers are other wine writers, which judging by the multiple hits that Uncorked experiences on a daily basis, implies that wine writing is alive and well in SA. A related point is made by Ken Forrester who e-mails that SA is the only country in the world where winewriters write about each other, rather than wine. Which says something about SA wine and SA wine writers, but I’m not sure what!

To continue this proud tradition and for my many frenemies over at Grape, a scurrilous appendix to my open letter to Angela Lloyd which has assumed cult status among the many PR agencies that have experienced the rough side of Angela’s tongue.

al

A quondam provincial treasure of Cape wine (and Living Legend in waiting), Angela is in all kinds of hot water with her response to comments on her Nederburg/CWG Auction posting on the Grape vanity blog. Taken to task by interlocutor WC for implicitly slagging off Nederburg Auctioneer Stephan Welz for his performance at an event she did not bother to attend, in defending her charge that last month’s Auction had lost its glamour, she repeats the slander “make no mistake, I would be delighted if the Nederburg Auction could recapture its past prestige, but I do wonder whether Distell has the will or ability.”

For good measure, WC is labeled a “piss pot” for taking the trouble to comment, Angela mistaking a commode for famous British statesman Winston Churchill, admittedly an easy mistake to make, given Winnie’s shiny pate. Talk about yellow journalism, as one PR commented!

Few would disagree that the little room would have been the best place for Angela to leave her ruminations on events she knows nothing about and concentrate on tasting the stuff, about which she has plenty to say. Meanwhile, Uncorked’s in-box is full to overflowing with congratulations on our original open letter to our dipsomaniacal diva, confirming that the sighted tasting policy for the most excellent Platter guide where Angela serves as kingmaker and queen bee, ensures that objections to her imperious reign need be made anonymously and in private lest revenge be wrecked in the pages of the guide, dripping as it is with red ink like the stabbed victims of this Lucrezia Borgia of the Bottle.

On a lighter note, Uncorked is off to Paarl this evening for the KWV retirement plegtigheid for outgoing chairman Danie de Wet. Johann Rupert is guest speaker and informed rumour has it that the function will be “an evening to treasure.” Hopefully Angela RSVP’d in time as another breathy report about a function she did not attend would be too nerve wracking.

Danie de Wet and an admirer

Danie de Wet and an admirer

Related posts:

  1. Open letter to Angela Lloyd Dear Angela Your comments on the Nederburg and Cape Winemakers...
  2. From Andy to Angela Reading the first 2010 blog posting from Angela Lloyd, most...
  3. Jane & Angela & Bernard Jane MacQuitty is wine pundit on The Thunderer. She has...
  4. Mega-Tasting Disappoints Was this week’s biennial SA generic wine tasting in London...
  5. Slagged-Off in the Open The Grape communal blog is divided into eight panels like...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

 


Comments

 

Peter

October 13, 2009 at 5:24 pm

Ah go on with you there. Is WC not your alter ego ?

(I thought an interlocutor was a knitting machine cross-stitch, just shows how little I know.)

Nevertheless, how about that break-down of the wine industry players that I requested over on Grape. Who judges what, who has their hand in which pocket etc. It would be a most entertaining read for Joe Public. No-one seems to be rising to the bait.

 

Affieplaas

October 13, 2009 at 9:50 pm

I don’t think folk who gripe as much as old lady vinegar should garner “Wine Legend” status – especially when the Legends sport the league of Prof. Piet Gossard, Spatz Sperling and some damn fine other gentle folk – some few woman in there as well Norma and Phyllis – who have really tangibly contributed to the industry.
A missappointment like that would surely tarnish the brand value and could like destroy the visually impaired wine awards.

I also find it funny that the five star cream doesn’t float to the top when the cats can’t see the bottles or maybe the double thick version doesn’t float too well.

 

Neil

October 13, 2009 at 11:45 pm

Hi Peter

Nope, I’m not WC.

If the tastings are blind, what does it matter whose hand is in whose pocket? The problem comes with sighted tourneys and I’ve ventilated on this extensively.

 

Peter

October 14, 2009 at 9:03 am

Hi Neil.

It’s not just about tastings and judges’ alignments.

It is also about ‘learned’ articles. How can Joe P judge the value of an article when he doesn’t know who is actually paying the piper ? How much of the incisive comment is actually heavily disguised advertorial ?

 

Marc Afton-Cooper

October 14, 2009 at 3:16 pm

Making a cult of yourself ?
I see you claim that your open letter has assumed cult status, and that your e-mail in-box is overflowing with hearty congrats.
Yet the original post only got 4 comments, one of which is cut-and-paste by yourself and another has been removed (censored?).
Why this silence on your blog comments page? Do you think everyone is scared of you making a cult of yourself in public?

 

Matthew

October 14, 2009 at 5:00 pm

Shame Marc

Once again you’ve misunderstood the posting. The whole point is that people prefer to congratulate Pendock in private as a public message might invite retribution in a sighted guide…

Stop making a cult of yourself!



Leave a Comment





Afrigator