The tippler’s poll at last month’s WineX in Cape Town kicks some serious anoraque butt. The top three slots for favourite red went to coffee/mocha style Pinotages in the shape of the Diemersfontein 2008, KWV Café Culture 2009 and Barista Coffee Pinotage 2009. Voting with their wallets, WineX punters also made Diemersfontein the top selling wine at the show, both in terms of volumes and value. Pity I neglected to secure a royalty deal when I handed Diemersfontein owner David Sonnenberg the soubriquet People’s Pinotage for this wine.

Diemersfontein @ WineX

Diemersfontein @ WineX

Disturbingly for the Pinotage Association, not one of the top three WineX reds made the Absa Top Ten although the reduced coffee/mocha Diemersfontein Carpe Diem 2007 did make the Top Twenty. Of course none of the WineX Three got Platter five stars – but then wines are nominated sighted and it would be inconceivable for the sighted pundits to stoop so low as to nominate a coffee/mocha Pinotage for five star status. Anthony Hamilton Russell was in Jozi last week soliciting support for an alternative Pinotage competition – a salon de refusés if you like – of wines ignored by the Absa competition. Although quite whether he’d be in favour of a competition sponsored by Vida e Caffè is moot. Bom dia!

WineX whites were more on message: top of the pops was Abrie Bruwer’s Springfield Life From Stone Sauvignon Blanc 2009 for all of R69 a bottle, followed by the Hamilton Russell Chardonnay 2008 – nominated for five Platter stars but not awarded, which reflects badly on the pundits as this wine is in the top three Chardonnays for the vintage IMHO – plus the Ataraxia 2008, the CWG version of which commanded R3500 a six pack at Saturday’s Cape Winemakers Guild Auction and which was a Platter five star stunner, having been nominated sighted.

Cafe Culture

Cafe Culture

Related posts:

  1. Donkiesbaai fermenter crashlands in Namibia The spittoon is foaming over the identity of the author...
  2. Coffee Pinotage: Spilling the Beans From today’s Travel & Food supplement of The Sunday Times....
  3. Pinotage Red Bull Things were a little more surreal than usual this Sunday...
  4. Prodding Platter Pinotage Punditry Positive Pinotage article in the Wine Enthusiast this month. Which...
  5. Beyers follows Mao with a new little red book This life as a Boswell to the Good Value Guru...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

 


Comments

 

Wayne Elsom

October 6, 2009 at 7:29 am

Neil, as a wine lover and qualified mathematician, I am surprised to see you miss the Vrede en Lust unique performance at WineX Cape Town 2009. Two Vrede en Lust wines voted to the top-10 white wines as well as two Vrede en Lust red wines voted to the top-10 reds. I have never seen a winery achieve the double-double before.
The odds of getting these ratings, with 900 wines on show from 154 producers, are truly minute. Seems like the odds of your ever mentioning them are even smaller! This is the great thing about the attendee vote – its the buying public’s vote and that is the most important one. We buy the wines, not the anoracks or pundits.

 

Neil Pendock

October 6, 2009 at 7:37 am

Hi Wayne

Not fair! I only focus on the top three wines of each colour to suggest that there is serious prejudice against Pinotage and the coffee/mocha strain in particular in some circles.

Vrede en Lust is a powerful brand that doesn’t need any punting from me! I was pleased to see Johan Reyneke up in the top ten as this was my favourite wine as I blogged at the time.

 

Giuam

October 6, 2009 at 12:24 pm

Totally agree on the Reyneke wines. Tehy are fantastic with the top red blend of Syrah and Cab, once again stealing the show for me at the annual WineWorx/Vinimark tasting last week. Neil, don’t you judge at the ABSA Top 10 Pinotage? Did you vote for any of the Chocolate/Moccha Pinotage’s in the Top 10? Cheers

 

Neil Pendock

October 6, 2009 at 12:31 pm

Hi Giuam

Guilty as charged. Allan Cheesman, the UK judge, and I voted vigorously for a couple of coffee jobs, but alas, all in vain it seems.



Leave a Comment





Afrigator