All Times LIVE Blogs
Minor Matters
18 minutes ago
Common Dialogue
1 hour, 22 minutes ago
Good Times
7 hours, 1 minute ago
The 5th Official
7 hours, 21 minutes agoView all Times LIVE Blogs
A police report says that a man has appeared in court for allegedly insulting former president Nelson Mandela during a Potjiekos competition at Sun City near Rustenburg, North West. This is scary stuff, seeing that we all have constitutional rights to trade insults – or so I believed. Mandela doesn’t even know about the incident. Doesn’t the affected party have to open a case against the insulter for the case to go to court?
This guy’s only mistake is that he decided to launch a musical career by doing a kaffir version of the South African new national anthem and then threw in Nelson Mandela’s name there just to spice things up – also to do some big name calling just as rappers do if they want their albums to sell. As they say in rap lingo “drop it like it’s hot”.
According to the police report “it is alleged that during the competition he (Benjamin Burger, 46) played a CD…containing remixed lyrics of the national anthem, and people who attended the event listened to the song Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika, which continued to say Nelson Mandela is a kaffir.”
Now Benjamin is no student at the University of the Free State and neither does he stay at the univeristy’s Reitz residence. He is a grown up and a shareholder of Falcon Security Company which provides security services at the Sun City hotel, which incidentally hosted the Potjiekos competition. He was playing no prank, but was merely excercising his constitutional right to freedom of expression and enjoying whatever it is that Potjiekos competition contestants do. We can’t also rule out the possibility of him trying to launch a music career.
I mean our deputy police minister Fikile Mbalula has been trading insults with Kader Asmal. Words like lunatic were tossed about, and the MK veterans jumped in and spiced it up with stronger words like “find the nearest cemetery and die”. Julius Malema and Helen Zille have enjoyed that pastime too as we sat glued to our newspapers whisky and Cubans in hand. Riverting stuff.
Malema has basically traded insults with almost everyone from Cope to DA, and does not spare his own comrades in the ANC and SACP – Naledi Pandor and Blade Nzimande will attest to that.
Now that’s democracy at its best and I love it that way.
I don’t see anything wrong with Zuma’s “mshini wam” mixed with the hit single “kill the boer, kill the farmer” by the late Peter Mokaba and a dash of Mr Burger’s kaffirnated Nkosi sikele’iAfrika. I would make for a chart burning release, akin to Arthur “king of kwaito” Mafokate’s “Don’t call me kaffir”.
In Zimbabwe I am told people get arrested for making uncomplimentary statements about uncle Bob, and sometimes for just looking like a member of the movement for democratic something. We should not head that way.
Related posts:
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
All rights have limitations. Your freedom of movement is, for instance, controlled by access control, road rules, etc. Some restrictions on human rights are more obvious than others. Criminals have their right of movement and free association limited by being sent to prison. Some would argue, and I agree, that their right to vote must also be restricted. While our provisions on free speech are very liberal, “kaffir” and “one settler one bullit” are regarded as hate speech and must be seen as such. Personally I regard being called a racist in similar light. Our history simply does not afford anyone the right to apply that term without qualifying it. Arresting someone for this or hate speech in general is rediculous. Similarly: being found guilty of hate speech should not carry either jail time or a fine as sentencing. Community service should do the trick. Just my few cents worth…
One can not remix our national anthem and claim its freedom of expression, the National Anthem need to be respected and he can not be using the K… word in this world, those days have passed he deserves what ever come to him, l call upon Sun City to terminate their contract with Falcon Security Company.
We are on the rocky road to a totalitarian dictatorship under President Malema – just wait and see.
The world may implode before this according to Mayan prophesies
Churchill once said, if I am correct, that the world was for the few and for the very few.
Sensible man! Mandela could probably shuffle to a kwaito rap ditty all about a particularly bad-tasting white-pattied fatty artery-clogging junk food known as a “Benjaminburger”.
Look he’s out of line with the kaffir tag but all this shows is that only the white man can be racist. Stories like the Reitz 4 and this one receive global attention but no one gives a **** about the fact that true racist KAFFIRS invade white people’s homes and proceed to pour boiling water over them, cutting women’s breasts off before raping them and finally murdering (in many cases, those who do alot of charity work for blacks) white people. Again, only the white man can be racist.
wat about the four south africans who were arrested at botswana for saying the president looks like a khoisan?
Why can we all not live together in peace. That is what Mr Mandela fought for and that is what we recieved. Now is the time to live in it. Yes what Mr Burger did was not right, but comments given on this page also include insults. Jon, Me, Makalo and Scapegoat you feel offended by what Mr Burger said, but you are doing the same by insalting him now and others now. Let the law deal with Mr Burger and let us live in peace with oneather.
Lara Johnstone
October 27, 2009 at 8:55 pmWell Said, I agree!
Either everyone has free speech, or none of us do.
In a real democracy there is no such thing as the ‘right not to be insulted’.
Anyway, I called Mandela a ‘kaffir’ as an act of civil disobedience in 2007; and Mandela never filed any charges of ‘crimen injuria’ against me; so Mandela clearly must support the principle of freedom of expresison, over the ‘right not to be insulted’ (unlike Patricia de lille)
It will be interesting to find out who filed these charges against this man; whom was the person who ‘was unlawfully, intentionally and seriously insulted in their dignity’?
Lara